Teams Hugh Rotherham played for

Main FCMarylebone Cricket Club (1884)
 Warwickshire (1903)
Other FCEngland XI (1880-1884)
 Gentlemen of England (1880-1885)
 Gentlemen (1880-1884)
 Orleans Club (1882)
 CI Thornton's England XI (1883)
 AJ Webbe's XI (1885)
 EJ Sanders' XI (1886)
MiscellaneousUppingham School (1877-1879)
 Uppingham (1878)
 Uppingham Rovers (1879-1894)
 Gentlemen of Warwickshire (1880-1898)
 Coventry and North Warwickshire (1880-1908)
 Warwickshire (1883-1886)
 Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club (1884)
 EJ Sanders' XI (1886)
 RS Newhall's XI (1886)
 Free Foresters (1890)
 Coventry (1893)